10 Best Bed and Breakfasts in Cape May NJ: Top Picks for a Cozy Stay

10 Best Bed and Breakfasts in Cape May NJ. When it comes to finding the perfect getaway in Cape May, New Jersey, bed and breakfasts offer a unique and charming experience. These quaint accommodations provide a cozy atmosphere, often housed in historic Victorian homes, giving you a taste of both comfort and history.

In this guide, I will highlight the top 10 bed and breakfasts in Cape May, helping you choose the ideal spot for your next vacation. Whether you’re looking for a place near the beach or one with exceptional amenities, there’s something for everyone.

1) Angel of the Sea

I recently stayed at Angel of the Sea, and it was an incredible experience. Located just a half-block from the beach, this charming bed and breakfast offers a unique Victorian atmosphere with beautiful gingerbread detailing and an ocean-view wraparound porch. The ambiance is both romantic and relaxing.

The accommodations were quaint and provided modern amenities without losing the historic charm. My room had a private bath and was tastefully decorated. The staff were friendly and attentive, helping with dinner reservations and suggestions for things to do in Cape May.

One of the highlights of my stay was the delightful gourmet breakfast served each morning. In the afternoons, they offered tea, and in the evenings, wine and cheese were served on the porch. Beach chairs, bicycles, umbrellas, and towels were also available for guests, making beach outings easy and enjoyable.

Rating: 4.6 (355 reviews)
Location: [5 Trenton Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204]
Contact: (609) 884-3369
Website: Visit Website

2) Highland House

I felt instantly at home when I arrived at Highland House. This charming inn, dating back to the 1850s, offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere. The rooms are decorated in a country-cottage style, making each stay feel special. Highland House is known for its pet-friendly policy, welcoming both furry and feathered friends.

In the mornings, I enjoyed the complimentary continental breakfast, which was the perfect start to my day. The inn is located just four blocks from Cape May’s stunning beach, and nearby Wilbraham Park often hosts antique fairs and festivals. The location is ideal for exploring local dining options, antique shops, and gift shops.

One of my favorite things about Highland House is the relaxing outdoor spaces. The porch, decks, patio, and screened gazebo provided perfect spots to unwind. The gardens are beautifully maintained, adding to the serene atmosphere. It’s no wonder Highland House has won multiple awards for being the best pet-friendly bed and breakfast in Cape May.

Rating: 4.8 (88 reviews)
Location: 131 Broadway, West Cape May, NJ 08204
Contact: (609) 898-1198
Website: Visit Website

3) Mainstay Inn Bed and Breakfast Cape May

The Mainstay Inn in Cape May is a place that transports you back to the elegant times of the late 19th century. Walking through its halls, you can sense the history. Designed by Stephen Decatur Button in 1872, this inn once served as a private gambling club.

The atmosphere is charming with antique furnishings that add a touch of opulence. The rooms are cozy, filled with unique vintage pieces. It’s easy to imagine the grand parties that once took place here. Having afternoon tea in the lush garden feels like stepping into another era.

During my visit, I stayed in one of the rooms in “The Cottage,” which is right next to the main building. The brick walkway and beautiful Victorian fountain make the stroll between the two a delightful experience. The current owners, Pete and Esther Scalone, continue to maintain the inn’s charm and exceptional hospitality.

Rating: 4.5 (89 reviews)
Location: 635 Columbia Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204
Contact: (609) 884-8690
Website: Visit Website

4) Wilbraham Mansion

Wilbraham Mansion offers a unique mix of Victorian charm and modern amenities. The mansion, which dates back to the 1840s, feels like stepping back in time with its historic decor. The newer suites maintain the classic look but come with modern comforts, including Jacuzzi® jetted tubs in many rooms.

Each stay includes breakfast and afternoon tea. The indoor heated pool is a great spot to relax, especially on cooler days. The atmosphere is peaceful and welcoming, making it an ideal choice for a getaway.

The mansion is adults-only, accepting guests 12 years and older. This ensures a quiet and relaxing environment. It’s also conveniently located, making it easy to explore Cape May’s beautiful beaches, historic sites, and various activities.

Rating: 4.6 (216 reviews)
Location: 133 Myrtle Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204
Contact: (609) 884-2046
Website: Visit Website

5) John Wesley Inn Bed and Breakfast

I recently visited the John Wesley Inn Bed and Breakfast in Cape May. The Victorian charm is captivating. The richly decorated rooms make it feel cozy and welcoming. Each room’s attention to detail adds to the overall experience.

I stayed in one of the Carriage House Apartments. Apartment A offered plenty of space with its two floors. The private porch and balcony provided a lovely place to relax in the evening.

Apartment B was just as impressive. The spiral staircase and fireplaces on each floor made it feel special. Both apartments had fully equipped kitchens, making my stay comfortable. The location was perfect for exploring Cape May’s attractions.

Rating: 4.5 (30 reviews)
Location: [30 Gurney St, Cape May, NJ 08204]
Contact: (609) 884-1012
Website: Visit Website

6) The Southern Mansion

I recently stayed at The Southern Mansion in Cape May. This grand 1860s mansion is truly something special. It’s located in the heart of the historic district and is just a short walk from the beach, shops, and restaurants. The lush, award-winning gardens around the mansion make it feel like a peaceful retreat.

The rooms are the largest I’ve seen in a bed and breakfast. Each one has antique furnishings that really make you feel like you’ve stepped back in time. My room even had a private bathroom with a hand-painted tile shower, which was a lovely touch.

One of the highlights of my stay was the full gourmet breakfast. It’s not just about the food, though. The hospitality is genuine, and everyone there made me feel very welcome and at home. During the summer, they even provide beach chairs and towels, which is quite convenient.

For those planning a wedding, The Southern Mansion offers a unique venue option. It seamlessly blends Victorian elegance with modern comforts, making it perfect for a special day. If you’re looking for something different from the typical wedding hall or hotel, this might be the place for you.

Rating: 4.4 (262 reviews)
Location: 720 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Contact: (609) 884-7171
Website: Visit Website

7) Elaine’s Cape May

Elaine’s Cape May offers a unique experience right in the heart of Cape May. I enjoyed the elegant setting where you can have meals and cocktails in style. The place has a restaurant, a cozy pub, and an outdoor bar which make it a perfect spot to relax.

Live music is a highlight at Elaine’s. Every day, you can catch performances that add to the vibrant atmosphere. It was lovely to sip a drink on the patio or the deck lounge areas while enjoying Cape May’s lively vibes.

This place is more than just a bed and breakfast. Elaine’s Boutique on the Washington Street Mall adds a shopping element to your stay. It’s always fun to explore the local stores during my visit.

Rating: 4 (774 reviews)
Location: 513 Lafayette St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Contact: (609) 884-1199
Website: Visit Website

8) Captain Mey’s Inn

Captain Mey’s Inn is a charming place to stay in Cape May. The frilly rooms make you feel like you’re in another era. Some rooms even have whirlpool tubs, which is a nice touch when you want to relax after a day of exploring.

The guesthouse has a laid-back vibe. It’s seasonal, so it’s best to check if they’re open when you plan to visit. Staying connected isn’t a problem since they offer free Wi-Fi. Even though the atmosphere is relaxed, the service is prompt and welcoming.

It’s within walking distance of many attractions in Cape May. The location makes it easy to explore the town without needing a car. You can enjoy various activities, from beach walks to dining at local restaurants.

Rating: 4.1 (39 reviews)
Location: 202 Ocean St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Contact: (609) 884-7793
Website: Visit Website

9) Buttonwood Boutique Hotel

I recently had the pleasure of staying at the Buttonwood Boutique Hotel in Cape May, NJ. The hotel is located on Broadway, which is a great spot near many local attractions. The elegant and charming decor makes it a lovely place to stay.

The rooms are spacious and well-appointed. I found that the staff are attentive and friendly, always ready to help with any needs or questions. The ambiance is relaxed and welcoming, making it easy to feel at home.

One of the highlights for me was the convenient access to the beach and nearby shops. I enjoyed exploring the area and then coming back to the comfort of my cozy room. The hotel offers a unique and pleasant experience for anyone visiting Cape May.

Rating: 4.6 (53 reviews)
Location: 115 Broadway, Cape May, NJ 08204
Contact: (856) 506-5743
Website: Visit Website

10) Carroll Villa Hotel

I recently stayed at the Carroll Villa Hotel in Cape May, and it was a delightful experience. The hotel, built in 1882, is full of Victorian charm and has a warm, welcoming atmosphere. It’s just a short walk to the beach, making it perfect for a seaside getaway.

The 19 guest rooms are uniquely decorated, and each room has a modern touch while keeping its old-time charm. Families with children, couples looking for a romantic stay, or anyone wanting a cozy retreat will feel at home here. Despite its age, the hotel provides all the contemporary amenities needed for a comfortable stay.

Attached to the hotel is The Mad Batter Restaurant, known as one of Cape May’s best places to eat. The food is exceptional, and locals and tourists alike love dining there. I enjoyed my meals thoroughly, and the dining vouchers provided by the hotel were a nice bonus.

Rating: 4.5 (394 reviews)
Location: 19 Jackson St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Contact: (609) 884-9619
Website: Visit Website

History of Bed and Breakfasts in Cape May

Cape May, New Jersey, has a rich history that dates back to the early 18th century. As a seaside resort town, it quickly became a favorite among tourists.

In the 19th century, many Victorian-style homes were built. These grand houses set the stage for the bed and breakfast tradition.

Victorian Influence
The Victorian era was a significant time for Cape May. The architecture from this period is known for its elaborate designs and ornate details. Today, many bed and breakfasts in Cape May still retain these charming Victorian elements.

John Wesley Inn
One example is the John Wesley Inn. This inn, built in 1869, embodies the era’s Gothic style. Its history and elegance make it a notable spot in Cape May’s bed and breakfast scene.

Preservation Efforts
Efforts to preserve these historic homes began in the mid-20th century. The community recognized the importance of maintaining these historic structures. Many of these homes were restored and converted into bed and breakfasts.

Modern Adaptations
Over the years, owners have modernized these locations to meet today’s standards while keeping their historical charm. Modern amenities blend seamlessly with antique furnishings, offering a unique mix of old and new.

Notable Mentions
Other popular bed and breakfasts include The Virginia Hotel and the Mainstay Inn. Each of these places has its own unique history and style, contributing to Cape May’s rich tapestry of hospitality.

What to Expect at a Bed and Breakfast

Staying at a bed and breakfast offers a unique and intimate lodging experience. You can look forward to personalized service, distinct accommodations, and homemade breakfasts.

Personalized Service

One of the best parts of staying at a bed and breakfast is the personalized service. Innkeepers often go out of their way to make guests feel at home. I find the staff frequently provides local insights, such as the best nearby attractions or dining spots.

Often, you’ll be greeted by name and treated like a special guest rather than just another customer. This can make your stay feel more welcoming and tailored to your needs.

Special requests, such as dietary restrictions or special occasions, are usually handled with great care and attention. The small size of bed and breakfasts allows for this level of personal attention.

Unique Accommodations

Another highlight of bed and breakfasts is the unique accommodations. Each room typically has its own style, often reflecting the history or character of the building. I’ve noticed that many of these places are housed in historic Victorian homes.

Rooms might feature antique furniture, original artwork, or cozy fireplaces. Unlike standard hotel rooms, no two rooms are exactly alike. This can make your stay feel more special and memorable.

In some cases, you might even find themed rooms or unusual decor that adds to the charm. This uniqueness sets bed and breakfasts apart and adds a touch of character to your trip.

Homemade Breakfasts

A key feature of bed and breakfasts is the homemade breakfast. Each morning, you can expect to enjoy a freshly prepared meal. I often find these breakfasts include a variety of options such as fresh fruit, baked goods, and hot entrees.

Many innkeepers take pride in using local ingredients, which can give you a taste of the region. Breakfast is often served in a communal dining area, allowing guests to chat and share experiences.

The quality and care put into these meals are usually high, making breakfast a highlight of the day. It’s a chance to start your day on a delicious and satisfying note.

Tips for Choosing the Right Bed and Breakfast

When selecting a bed and breakfast, focus on your individual preferences, read reviews for authentic experiences, and communicate directly with the host to ensure your stay meets your needs.

Consider Your Preferences

First, think about what you want. Do you prefer a modern or Victorian style? Some places, like the John Wesley Inn, have a Victorian look, while others might be more contemporary.

Next, location matters. If you like being near the beach, choose a spot like Luther Ogden Inn, which is close to both the beach and the Washington Street Mall.

Think about amenities. Do you want free Wi-Fi, a fireplace, or a private bathroom? Listing your must-haves helps narrow choices.

Check Reviews and Ratings

Reviews and ratings are valuable. Sites like U.S. News Travel offer insights into guests’ experiences. High ratings can indicate quality, but read individual reviews for details.

Look for patterns in reviews. Consistent praise for cleanliness or complaints about noise are worth noting. Don’t focus only on the overall rating but consider the specifics of what people say. For example, if several reviews mention a fantastic breakfast, that’s a good sign.

Check recent reviews for the most accurate information. Businesses can change, and recent feedback may reflect the current state better.

Contact the Host

Talking to the host can provide clarity. Reach out through email or phone to ask questions about the property, policies, and amenities. A good host should be responsive and helpful.

Ask about check-in/check-out times, parking, breakfast options, and any special requests you might have. This can ensure there are no surprises when you arrive.

If you have dietary restrictions or special needs, mention them to make sure they can accommodate you. Communicating directly often gives a better feel for the place and the people running it.