10 Best Restaurants in Cape May NJ: Top Dining Spots for Every Taste
Whether you're into seafood, Italian cuisine, or farm-to-table dishes, this guide will help you uncover the best places to eat in this quaint seaside town. From waterfront dining to cozy bistros, Cape May's culinary scene is as diverse as it is delicious.
1. [The Lobster House](https://www.thelobsterhouse.com/)
No list of Cape May restaurants is complete without the Lobster House. This waterfront institution on Fisherman's Wharf serves some of the freshest seafood you'll find anywhere. The raw bar is legendary, and the lobster bisque is a must-try. For a more casual experience, grab a seat on the outdoor deck of the Schooner Bar.
2. Washington Inn
Set in a beautifully restored 1840s plantation house, the Washington Inn offers fine dining in an elegant setting. The menu changes seasonally, featuring dishes like pan-seared diver scallops and herb-crusted rack of lamb. Their wine list has won Wine Spectator awards multiple years running.
3. The [Ebbitt Room](https://www.virginiahotel.com/ebbitt-room)
Located in the Virginia Hotel, the Ebbitt Room is Cape May's most acclaimed fine dining destination. Chef-driven seasonal menus showcase the best of local ingredients, from Jersey corn to fresh-caught fish. The tasting menu with wine pairings is an unforgettable experience.
4. Lucky Bones Backwater Grille
A local favorite for casual dining, Lucky Bones serves excellent burgers, ribs, and craft cocktails in a lively atmosphere. The outdoor patio is perfect for warm evenings, and their happy hour specials are some of the best in town.
5. Aleathea's at the Inn of Cape May
This charming restaurant combines Victorian elegance with creative American cuisine. Sunday brunch is particularly popular, featuring dishes like crab cake Benedict and lemon ricotta pancakes.
6. Peter Shields Inn
Housed in a stunning Georgian Revival mansion, Peter Shields offers refined coastal cuisine with ocean views. The prix fixe menu is an excellent value, and the sunset views from the dining room are spectacular.
7. The Rusty Nail
A beachfront bar and grill that's perfect for families and groups. The atmosphere is casual and fun, with live music on summer weekends. The fish tacos and craft beer selection are standouts.
8. George's Place
A breakfast and lunch spot beloved by locals. George's serves generous portions of Greek-inspired dishes alongside classic American breakfast fare. The gyro omelette is a local legend.
9. Tisha's Fine Dining
An intimate BYOB restaurant that punches well above its weight. Chef Tisha creates inventive dishes using local ingredients, and the small dining room ensures personal attention. Reservations are essential.
10. Cape May Fish Market
For the freshest catch prepared simply and deliciously, the Fish Market is hard to beat. Order at the counter, grab a seat on the patio, and enjoy perfectly grilled fish with a view of the harbor.
For more seafood-focused dining, see our in-depth guide to the best seafood restaurants in Cape May. Don't miss Uncle Bill's Pancake House for breakfast, and explore the new shops on Washington Street Mall for a full Cape May dining experience.
